zahrcast
zahrcast · interim decisions in oncology

Bayesian forecasting for oncology trials in flight

Sia forecasts the results an ongoing trial will report at maturity, with credible intervals, from the data collected so far. It links each patient's disease burden to progression and death, and borrows from historical trials.

the problem

deciding on immature data

Interim decisions come a few months into follow-up, when most patients are still censored. The usual answer is to wait for more events. Enrollment and spending continue while you wait, and a pivotal trial costs a median of about $19m.1

The burden measurements already collected often carry information about the final result that an event count does not use.

what you get

The range of results the trial could still report, with the probability of each. The same output answers:

  • go/no-go, as the probability that the benefit exceeds a threshold you choose
  • whether to stop an arm
  • how to size the next study
  • any endpoint: progression-free and overall survival, response rate, hazard ratios
how sia works

disease burden, then events

Most interim methods extrapolate a survival curve from the events observed so far. Sia models each patient's disease burden over time and derives progression and death from it. A patient with four assessments adds little to an event count, but a lot to an estimate of their trajectory.

disease burdenmonths on study1 · fit

Fit to each patient's measurements and events so far, borrowing from historical trials.

disease burdenmonths on studytoday2 · roll forward

Simulate each patient forward from today, thousands of times. Some futures end in progression.

share alivemonths on studymediansarm Aarm B3 · read off

Each simulation is a completed trial. Read any endpoint off them, with its uncertainty.

probabilities

Every forecast comes with its uncertainty, as a credible interval or a probability.

borrowing

Sia estimates how much to borrow from historical trials. When they disagree, it borrows less.

checked

Forecasts are scored against data that arrived after the cut-off they were made at.

case studies

forecasts checked against the observed results

Sia was fitted at early cut-offs of completed trials and checked against their final results.2

extensive-stage small-cell lung cancer

Lilly CXCR4 trial

patients
77 in two arms
cut-offs
trial months 4, 11 and 19
borrowed
one historical trial
endpoints
progression-free and overall survival
metastatic colorectal cancer

Amgen PACCE trial

patients
739 in two arms
cut-offs
trial months 6, 15 and 22
borrowed
three historical trials
endpoints
progression-free and overall survival
metastatic castration-resistant prostate cancer

ENTHUSE-33 trial

patients
436 in one arm
cut-offs
trial months 7, 19 and 31, on simulated enrollment
borrowed
two historical trials
endpoints
progression-free and overall survival
metastatic pancreatic cancer

MPACT trial

patients
403 in one arm
cut-offs
trial months 5, 14 and 24, on simulated enrollment
borrowed
two historical trials
endpoints
progression-free and overall survival
contact

if you have a trial in flight

references
  1. Moore TJ, Zhang H, Anderson G, Alexander GC. Estimated costs of pivotal trials for novel therapeutic agents approved by the US Food and Drug Administration, 2015–2016. JAMA Internal Medicine. 2018;178(11):1451–1457. doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2018.3931.
  2. This publication is based on research using information obtained from www.projectdatasphere.org, which is maintained by Project Data Sphere. Neither Project Data Sphere nor the owner(s) of any information from the web site have contributed to, approved or are in any way responsible for the contents of this publication.